‘Tis the season, again

Well, it’s that time of the year again, when Christians start imagining themselves to be oppressed because their hegemony isn’t absolutely complete, and atheists find themselves wondering if it’s OK to have a coniferous tree in the house and some lights on the roof, and lots of folks are in a bit of a bind over whether to wish people a “Merry Christmas” or “Happy Holidays” or whatever.

My own feeling on the whole greetings topic is (as regular readers might guess) one of “live and let live” (and that’s why I’m not calling this a Sunday Sermon, just a blog post that happens to be going up on a Sunday). Cut people some slack, as long as they’re not being huge jerks about the whole thing. If a greeting seems sincere and well-intentioned, but it turns out to be inappropriately placed (e.g. wishing a non-Christian a Christmas greeting), I say let it slide.

But of course, not all such greetings are innocuous. One of the ironies of the War On The War On Christmas is that there are a lot of folks who are denying the true meaning of Christmas (whatever that is) by using “Merry Christmas” not as a greeting, but as a salvo, a shot across the bow of an imagined enemy in an imaginary war. There are people who say “Merry Christmas” in what they perceive to be a daring act of defiance, uttering a forbidden phrase in brave defense of a religion that only claims 3 out of 4 Americans.

If you find someone doing that, saying “Merry Christmas” as a soft of “you and me against the evil hordes” gesture, I don’t see any problem with politely explaining that you’re one of the hordes. People who make those sort of presumptions, and try to enlist your help in reinforcing their presumptions, deserve to be enlightened about the foible of their worldview.

But most people aren’t like that. Usually, if someone’s wishing you “Merry Christmas,” it’s a misguided but well-intentioned gesture of goodwill. Likewise (though IMO to a lesser extent) with “Happy Holidays” — there might be a few militant types who use it as a cudgel to beat people over the head with the fact that lots of people aren’t celebrating Jesus’ birth, but in general it’s merely a way to wish someone a seasonal greeting, perhaps with an added element of inclusiveness to embrace not only Christians but others as well (note to Christians: Are you celebrating a holiday? Would you like it to be happy? If you answered “yes” to both questions, then you’ve got nothing to complain about).

But what about us? What greetings should we offer? Is it some sort of problem if we wish someone “Merry Christmas”? I don’t think so. Some people may choose to discipline themselves to avoid the phrase they were brought up saying, just as they may choose to discipline themselves to say something other than “bless you” when someone sneezes, but I don’t think it’s worth getting all in a tizzy about your (or someone else’s) choice in that matter. Do it, or don’t do it, as you see fit, and as for what others do, live and let live.

It’s not like Christianity has a trademark (now or any time of the year) on “goodwill toward men” (and women). They co-opted it, just as they co-opted pagan symbols like fir trees and yule logs. Being nice to people isn’t a Christian thing, it’s just a thing. It’s my thing, and it can be your thing too no matter what you believe about imaginary deities.

(pic via Changing Places)

4 responses to this post.

  1. Posted by Gordon on December 6, 2010 at 7:21 am

    I refuse to see Christmas as a religious holiday, or to allow the christian grinches to steal it from the rest of us. Christmas is for everyone.


  2. I say “Enjoy your holidays” whenever I remember that we are in a war on Christmas. That statement is a well wish that is not presumptive and can apply to everyone, even the hard core, militant solstice junkie! It conveys a well wish without signaling your agreement to superstition, and it is completely innocuous and non offensive.

    Besides, whenever someone does get huffy about it, they can be taken to task for being far too sensitive!


  3. Posted by Jamie on December 7, 2010 at 10:25 pm

    I agree with Gordon. Christmas was never really religious for me. As a child it was all about presents and now its about family food and tradition. We send out cards, have a tree, stockings and even did pictures with Santa. I love and celebrate everything about the season except the weather and jesus.


  4. Posted by Huck Finn on December 8, 2010 at 6:23 pm

    Thanks for the site and the interesting discussions!

    I’m sure that you’re all aware of the history of the seasonal observances, and likewise assume that you’ve all heard the cliched “keep Christ in Christmas” from the good bible readers. You’ve also probably either wasted your breath or not even bothered trying to discuss the real roots of the events and traditions, as have I. Something that might be of interest to you all is the argument against christmas and all its trappings as a christian event or having roots in the bible, as articulated by a christian minister.

    I’m not sure how I found it but I ended up stumbling into David Pack’s “Restored Church of God” website, shortly after I read the current AE piece. Yes…I know he’s not considered a “real Christian” by the other “real Christians”, but he does reference handy biblical passages, along with other more fact based writings. His goal is certainly not to promote a repudiation of imaginary friends, but his arguments might leave the “keep Christ in Christmas” crowd with something to think about.

    You can find the video of Pack’s “Christmas Unveiled—What God Says!” by going to the website (http://www.worldtocome.org) and doing a search for it there. The video is 27 minutes long and I encourage you to enjoy the whole thing, but you can get the main points in the first half of the presentation. Hopefully you’ll find a few good nuggets as discussion points if you’re assaulted upon wishing someone “Happy Holidays!”

    oh…and Seasons Greetings to All!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

<span>%d</span> bloggers like this: